Allison Holker came back to the July 27th episode of So You Think You Can Dance as an Allstar to dance with Marko Germar in a Contemporary Sonja Tayeh routine about damaging someone and basking in the guilt so much that you want to do better by them.

The number, which was performed to I Know it’s Over by Jeff Buckley, brought Lady Gaga to tears. She said “I am just so proud of you,” and could not finish speaking for a bit. “You really love to dance and I know your mom is here [She had flewn in from Guam]. There were so many things I did wrong when I was young and so many things I wish I could take back…and I felt every moment of that through your dance tonight.”

Mary Murphy called Marko amazing and said he is sincere and honest in his style. She said he is still and by far her favorite dancer on the show.

Nigel Lythgoe said this was a remarkable moment since Marko had the opportunity to thank his mother.

Watch the performance below: