Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth Tweeted some festive photos on Christmas which, as has become the norm for Miley, have sparked some major rumors and controversy.

So, what’s the big hoopla with these seemingly harmless photos showing the couple in Santa hats and Miley in leopard print pajamas? Well, some people are pointing to the rings spotted on Miley and Liam’s fingers and starting the “are they married” rumors.

Let’s take a closer look. In the photo to the left, Liam is wrapping his arm lovingly around Miley–but he’s also sporting what looks like a wedding band on his wedding ring finger. In the photo to the right, Miley is inadvertently showing off a band and engagement ring on her left hand. So, could it be that the couple secretly tied the knot without us knowing it? Or are the dynamic duo just messing with our heads?

What do you think? A photo is worth a thousand words –so, how about two photos? Before you answer, you may recall, Liam already told an audience in June that he and Miley are already married before changing his tune and saying “We’re not married yet… but we will be.” Watch Liam make the ‘mistake?’ in the video clip below: